Question 1
29 marks
Graph theory routes, spanning trees and waiting times
- Geometry and trigonometry
- Statistics and probability
(a)(i)
2 marks
- Order the rows and columns and put a wherever two junctions share a road, otherwise.
- No road loops back to its own junction, so the leading diagonal is all zeros, and the matrix is symmetric because the roads are two-way.
Mentor tip
Check the row sums against the degrees: and have 3 roads, and have 4, has 2. They should add to .
(a)(ii)
3 marks
- The number of walks of length 4 between two vertices is the matching entry of .
- Raise the matrix to the fourth power on the GDC and read row , column .
Mentor tip
Write the power you used and the row you read. A bare 26 gives no evidence of the method.
(b)(i)
1 mark
Either of the standard minimum spanning tree algorithms works here.
Mentor tip
Prim's is often easier from a table like this one, because you work column by column.
(b)(ii)
3 marks
- Using Kruskal: list the roads from cheapest to dearest and add each one unless it closes a cycle.
- Stop once all five junctions are joined, which takes roads.
Another way. Prim's from picks , then , and : the same tree.
Mentor tip
Show the order you chose the edges in and say why was skipped. The order is the evidence that you actually ran the algorithm.
(b)(iii)
2 marks
Add the times for the four roads, then multiply by the rate of kg per minute.
Mentor tip
The table is in minutes, not kilograms. Remember to convert at the end.
(c)(i)
4 marks
- Every road must be swept and he returns to , so this is a Chinese postman problem: we need a closed walk covering every edge.
- Degrees: , , , , . Only and are odd.
- The two odd vertices must be joined by repeating the shortest path between them. Direct takes ; via it takes . So repeat .
- Minimum time is the total of all roads plus the repeated .
Mentor tip
46 is the length of a route that sweeps every road once but finishes at . Since he has to end at , you must add the repeated road.
(c)(ii)
1 mark
Write down any closed walk from that uses every road once and twice. It has length , the Chinese postman minimum, so nothing shorter is possible.
Mentor tip
Tick off all eight roads as you write the route, and check that it starts and ends at .
(d)(i)
1 mark
The only road he drives twice is . If any other road doubles, he still has to sweep it once and the repeated remains the cheapest link between the odd vertices, so the route is unchanged.
Mentor tip
Doubling a road that is swept only once adds its time but never changes the pairing of odd vertices.
(d)(ii)
2 marks
- With at , sweeping it once adds to the base total.
- The repeat between and should now go via () rather than along again ().
- Compare with the original . Any other road doubling adds at most (road ), so this is the worst case.
Mentor tip
Do not just add : once becomes slow, you would take the detour through for the second trip.
(e)(i)
1 mark
The two passes are independent, and each has probability of no stop.
Mentor tip
This is at , which is a quick way to phrase it.
(e)(ii)
2 marks
Use the binomial distribution for one and two stops.
Mentor tip
Check: .
(e)(iii)
7 marks
- No stops means no waiting, so only one or two stops can give at least minutes.
- One stop: the wait is . Find .
- Two stops: the total of two independent waits is normal with mean and variance . Find .
- Weight each by the chance of that many stops from (e)(ii) and add.
Mentor tip
Add variances, not standard deviations: the sum has standard deviation , not . Also, (one wait doubled) is a different variable from .

